Speaker of the National Assembly Manzoor Nadir has rejected a request from Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed to participate virtually in a sitting of the National Assembly while in prison.
Nadir told the House that his authority as Speaker does not extend to overriding an order of the judiciary.
Nadir informed the National Assembly of his decision while addressing the broader question of whether a parliamentarian who has been sent to prison by an order of the court can participate in parliamentary proceedings.
In explaining his ruling, Nadir stressed the constitutional separation of powers among the executive, judiciary and legislature, and said each arm of the State must respect the authority vested in the others.
He pointed out that being an elected parliamentarian does not place a person outside the jurisdiction of the courts.
At the same time, the Speaker acknowledged that Mohamed’s detention on remand does not amount to a conviction or automatically bring his parliamentary membership to an end.
However, Nadir said continued membership of the National Assembly does not give a detained parliamentarian unrestricted right to participate in parliamentary proceeding without regard for the conditions of that detention.
The Speaker explained that his authority to regulate proceedings in the National Assembly is separate from the legal authority governing the detention and custody of a prisoner.
“The assembly must respect the independence of the judiciary. Just as the judiciary must respect the constitutional functions of parliament,” Nadir said.
He further stated that the Speaker could not use the authority of the office to interfere with a remand order.
“The speaker of the National Assembly has no authority by virtue of that office alone to override an order of remand or to compel the release or the production of a member lawfully detailed. Pursuing to a judicial order,” Nadir said.
“In this regard, I had to deny the request of the Honorable Member but I thought I put this in writing so that it forms part of our rulings until its change by law or by another speaker,” Nadir said.
The Speaker added that there had been several exchanges of communication concerning issues related to parliamentary sittings and said guidelines had been issued in keeping with the Standing Orders and the limits of the Speaker’s powers.











