The High Court has dismissed an application by Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed challenging the decision of Magistrate Abigail Gibbs to refuse him bail in a cybercrime matter.

As a result, Mohamed will remain on remand.

The prosecution had argued that there were substantial grounds to believe that, if released, Mohamed could commit further offences or interfere with witnesses and the administration of justice.

In opposing bail, the prosecution relied on the cumulative circumstances surrounding Mohamed’s other pending criminal matters, including allegations of witness intimidation and obstruction of justice, together with the circumstances of the cybercrime charge.

Mohamed’s attorneys argued that he had already been granted bail in his other matters and had complied with those bail conditions. They also maintained that the allegations against him remain unproven.

Magistrate Gibbs nevertheless refused bail after considering the circumstances collectively and the potential risk of further offending or interference with the criminal justice process.

Mohamed subsequently moved to the High Court, seeking to have the Magistrate’s decision quashed through judicial review.

Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif dismissed the application and upheld the Magistrate’s decision.

The Court found that a Magistrate considering bail is entitled to examine the cumulative circumstances surrounding an accused’s pending criminal matters when assessing the risks associated with granting bail.

However, the Court stressed that pending charges are unproven allegations and cannot, by themselves, be treated as evidence of guilt or automatically justify the refusal of bail.

Justice Chandra-Hanif also emphasised that judicial review was not an opportunity for the High Court to rehear Mohamed’s bail application or substitute its own decision for that of the Magistrate. Rather, the issue was whether the Magistrate had exercised her discretion lawfully and rationally.

See full review judgement below:

Loading Viewer...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here